Showing posts with label John Gidding. Show all posts
Showing posts with label John Gidding. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

Victorian money pits and the "Painted Ladies"

The Painted Ladies near Alamo Square, San Francisco


Oddly, the subject of Victorian architecture came up several times this past weekend.  Though beautiful, Victorians have always been just a tad fussy for my taste.   Nevertheless....


On Friday's Condé Nast Traveler blog, The World's Best Cities for Architecture Lovers, "... 14 cities—some iconic, others surprising— embody certain eras of architecture so much that they provide travelers with living, breathing (and free) design exhibits."  Some were predictable.  For instance, Miami's Historic District and South Beach have the largest collection of art deco architecture in the world.  Ok, I knew that one.  South Beach IS one of my favorite places. 


However, always amused by my own ignorance, the city listed as the the top spot for Victorian architecture was... Ditmus Park, Brooklyn, New York.  Brooklyn?  Really????  During my last visit to Brooklyn, I was cursing my friend, Josie, for dragging me to some flea market.  As for the Victorians.... nope.... didn't seem 'em. 


Victorians in Ditmas Park, Brooklyn, NY


For me, the San Francisco Bay Area had always been associated with Victorian style because of those iconic Painted Ladies.   Always good to learn something new.


Later, Saturday evening on HGTV's Curb Appeal the Block, John Gidding was rehabilitating the façade of this San Francisco Victorian that had seen better days.  Photos online are scarce, but this one shows the attention to detail that only a true Victorian can display.

John Gidding Designs

And, come to think about it...... I've always wondered why the budget for Curb Appeal the Block was $20,000 per makeover in Atlanta, GA, but closer to $30,000 in San Francisco, CA.

Hmmmmm.  "Enquiring minds" want to know.




While doing a bit of research... I got bored and started looking through weekend photos on Facebook.  My friend, Michael - a great photographer - is summering in Maine.  He posted a photo of this beauty from a some sightseeing adventure.   
photo, Michael Broché


Absolutely stunning... but, I'd be willing to bet that it was a chore to paint.  That, of course, brings up the logical question:  What IS the cost of painting a Victorian?  


Oh.My.God.  They ARE a money pit! 


Before the grand tally, consider the following background information.  San Francisco Victorians will serve as our reference point.

1.  The Victorian Era refers to homes that were built between 1850 and 1920.

2.  The bulk of the San Francisco Victorians were created between 1870 and 1906.

3.  Big picture:  These buildings are OLD!  Because of the age of these structures, some exterior maintenance is always required before painting.  Rotting boards???

4.  Understanding color:  Classic Victorians can have as many as 11 different paint colors on their architectural details.  {Oh, Lord... it just gets worse.  Think of all of those trips to the paint store.  And, the paint swatches.} 

5.  They must be painted by hand due to the trimwork details and that pesky zero-lot-line issue in San Francisco.  Think about it:  If you decide to power (spray) paint your home and it is located only 2 feet from your neighbor's, you will be spray painting their house, too.  Just guessing, but that is probably a bad idea. 

6.  The painter's nightmare.  An average of 200-300 man hours are required to paint a 2,500 sq ft Victorian.


And, the grand total for this little paint job is.... about $15,000.  Oh, and did I mention, they need to be repainted every 7 to 10 years.  As a caveat, the interiors are also notoriously difficult to remodel.   

San Francisco Victorians


Ignorance WAS bliss!  Now that all of the facts are known, they are INDEED a beautiful money pit!  Wait.... that doesn't sound particularly PC.  Perhaps, a labor of expensive love would be more appropriate.


Regardless, I think that I'll continue to admire them............... from a distance.   

Tuesday, June 5, 2012

Red revival

Bungalow with red door, John Gidding Design Inc. 

Gone are the days of the power red tie, and the 1980s are a distant memory.  As for red front doors... "Don't call it a comeback; {they've} been here for years!"  

Hopefully, LL Cool J will appreciate the poetic license.  And, red front doors are as popular today as they have ever been. 

San Francisco Victorian by Ken Fulk

They can, however, create a bit of a color conundrum.  Red front doors must be well executed or they become "expected"....a likely color choice.     
Beautiful home but... the color choices are predictable!

Don't get me wrong.  I'm not suggesting hot pink for the door in the photo above.  I just think that a little color fine-tuning might be in order to update the scene. 

So... consider the following front porch scenario:    White house, red brick foundation, concrete porch slab, light charcoal roofing, and white porch railings.   Oh, did I mention, the front door is going to be red?  Smoked paprika to be exact....
Paprika

What other colors does the porch need?????  The plan is to paint the concrete... resurfacing is just a costly pain in the a$$.  A porch swing, two rocking chairs, and a side table are also in the "need to be repainted" mix. 

Think think think.....  
First, a personal bias:  Front porches ARE a Southern staple and grounding element for many homes.  They welcome you, and they set the mood for the homestead.  Therefore, it must be amazing…. understated, functional, non-haphazard, and… amazing.  Did I say that before?????
For intance, the HGTV "Dream House" in California a couple of years ago was lovely... but definitely NOT Southern.   That entrance and attached porch were, quite honestly, a beautiful bore!   Give me some plants, a couple of chairs, a few lanterns, and a more substantial light fixture and we'd be cooking. 
Zzzzzzzzzz!    Photo from www.HGTV.com

We want something more like this.....


At this point, the only thing that is established is the color of the front door.  Paprika!  Got to start somewhere... what about the floor?
The good news, red goes with just about everything.

But, the color of the roof and the red brick need to be considered.  Slate grey or camel brown would be my first suggestions.
 Paint swatches, RalphLauren.com



Me thinks that someone is going to need to find a roofing shingle or climb a ladder to check out the exact color of that roof.  The tone of the floor color should be slightly darker than that of the roof but without distracting from the brick.  One trick is to look at the color of the mortar around the brick and then go 2 to 3 shades darker for the porch floor.  For instance, the black porch floor color in this next photo is just too dramatic.  It looks like someone tried to hit the "underline" feature while painting their house.

I'm also a believer in the John Gidding school-of-thought... the foundation of a home should be one of the darkest colors in order to visually ground the residence.  That green door'd thing looks like it could take flight.   I like the ideas... just not the execution.
Ok... back to the task at hand.  "Red-esque" door, slate or dark chamois for the floor...  Color for the chairs and accessories?
White???
 Photo from Coastal Living


Unfortunately, white against white doesn't POP.  What about brown or natural wood???



 Ok, I just ain't feeling the brown.  So, what about black and white?????   I think that this might just work.  Ignore the stone and imagine that it is brick......  We might just have a winning plan. 

At least, the idea of the red door has been settled!  The rest may take a few paint swatches.